Compass Box Whisky Company

Compass Box Whisky Tasting Notes

After we reported about The Compass Box Whisky Company and presented our Scotch Whisky Guide, we will, today, focus on the Compass Box Whisky Tasting Set, which contains vatted malt whiskies.

The Whiskies

Compass Box Whisky - Hedonsim, Spice Tree, Peat Monster, Oak Cross, Asyla

Compass Box Whisky – Hedonsim, Spice Tree, Peat Monster, Oak Cross, Asyla

The basic range is five whiskies, and I’m just going to give you my basic impressions of each.  I highly recommend you pick up a kit yourself, do your own tasting, and let us know what you think.  Every palate is different, so you’re almost guaranteed to get something I didn’t and to think something I found obvious to be totally wrong.  Again, that’s what makes whisky so enjoyable.  I’ve presented them in the order that I recommend tasting them.


The Compass Box Whisky Tasting Asyla

This is Compass Box’s blended whisky, containing both grain and malt.  Unlike most other blended whiskies, (think of Johnny Walker, etcetera) the malt in this is unpeated (this means that it was not treated with peat smoke).  So, while many blends hide their mediocre grain behind smoke, Asyla is fruity and creamy.  The nose is hugely vanilla (this whisky is all at least 10 years old), with hints of apples, pears, and white flowers.  The taste is fruit forward, with that creamy grain setting back in on the finish.  Water brings out the fruit on the nose, and adds some bright lemon to the taste.  It’s great neat, but you could make one hell of a Scotch and Soda with this!

Oak Cross

Oak Cross is a blend of Clynelish, Teaninich, and Dailuaine, aged partially in ex Bourbon barrels from America and partially in new French Oak barrels.  Like Asyla, this whisky is composed of 10-12 year olds, but that’s where the similarities stop.  The nose is baked fruit and cream, with a bit of savoriness in the back, while the palate is a mix of sticky fruits, light smoke, and spicy wood.  The new French oak really makes all the difference here, and is one of Mr. Glaser’s signature touches.  Water makes the whole thing more lively, with the spices really jumping out.  This is a great whisky to sip in the summer – not too heavy, but full of flavor.

The Spice Tree

The Compass Box Whisky Tasting

Spice Tree begins with the same spirit recipe as Oak Cross, but is aged entirely differently.  Only twenty percent is aged in Bourbon barrels (compared to the sixty percent of Oak Cross), and the rest is aged in new French Oak with specially charred heads on the barrels.  These heavily toasted heads give the whisky spicy-savory characteristics that you just can’t get any other way.  The nose is huge vanilla, ginger, raisin, and baked apple.  As soon as it hits your palate, it explodes with fruitcake and spice notes, and feels thick and creamy in the mouth.  Long, satisfying finish.  Water brings out the fruit and subdues the creaminess.  This is the whisky that turned me on to Compass Box in the first place.


Not often do we get bottling of Scottish grain whisky.  This is a blend of two whiskies, aged completely in ex Bourbon barrels.  Compared to malt it’s not nearly as fruity, but it more than makes up for this in its creaminess.  Hedonism smells like the perfect coconut crème brûlée, and the creme and burned sugar tastes really coat your palate and make you want another sip.  It truly is a unique whisky. I can’t recommend this enough.  I would, however, be careful with water on this, as it loses its sumptuousness quickly.

Peat Monster

A brilliant concoction of seaside bonfire Caol Ila balanced with phenolic Laphroaig and sweetly-smoky Ardmore.  I’m a big peat-head, and, in fact, a frequent drinker of all three malts in Peat Monster.  The nose has a sweet seaweed character, backed up with some honey and some earthiness.  As one might expect, the mouthfeel on this is all Islay – slick, oily, and palate-coating.  The flavors are very well balanced and elegant: a mix of peat, citrus, iodine, seawater, and a hint of fruit that gets more pronounced with water.

Compass Box Whisky Gift Set

Compass Box Whisky Gift Set


Again, I highly recommend you order yourself a Compass Box Gift Pack and taste for yourself.  Being able to take a sip of Oak Cross and then a sip of Spice Tree and to see what wood can really do to spirit is an invaluable experience.  In one little black box you get Christmas cake, a seaside fire, and spring flowers.  Now, where else are you going to get that?

Compass Box Delicious Whisky Ltd
Chiswick Studios
9 Power Road
London W4 5PY
+44 (0)20 8995 0899
6 replies
  1. La Sombra Sofisticada says:

    It would be wonderful if all spirit producers would offer gift sets like these. There are so much interesting stuff out there to try and a full bottle isn’t always optimally.

    • Stephen Pulvirent says:

      Diageo has over the years produced some decent gift sets. In particular, the coveted Port Ellen whiskies made appearances in a number of them, allowing you to get a taste of some very rare, very expensive, and highly collectible whisky at a fraction of the price.

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] like with wine or whisky, you want to drink your beer from the proper glassware.  For these styles I recommend either going […]

  2. […] me with a tasting kit as well as a few special samples, so stay tuned in the coming weeks for a tasting of the Compass Box range.  I have had most of the whiskies before, but by tasting them side by side, hopefully I’ll […]

  3. […] of the samples he was kind enough to give me, and I shall do so tomorrow.  Before I jump into the Compass Box whiskies themselves though, I want to give a little primer on how to get the most out of your whisky, no […]

Comments are closed.