$4 vs. $40 Socks: Which is the Better Value?

When you buy something using the affiliate links on our site, we may earn a small commission.

While socks may not exactly be a style enthusiast’s idea of a “sexy” subject, they can actually have a huge impact on the way your whole outfit looks. Today, we’ll compare $4 versus $40 socks, talk about the differences, advantages, and disadvantages of each, and determine why one costs 10 times as much as the other.

Why Socks Matter for your Outfits

Socks have a unique ability to add some color to the bottom half of your outfit and therefore, you can tie your entire outfit together; you can coordinate it with your shoes, your tie, or your pocket square. The only other two options are either to exchange your shoelaces or you can buy different colored shoes, which is a lot more expensive and those kinds of shoes are typically less versatile.

In our opinion, socks are a gentleman’s secret weapon to tying together an entire outfit and bringing it alive. For instance, I use socks to make a neat transition between my pants and my shoes without sacrificing contrast or visual interest. So the big question is, for an item that you need to replace regularly in your wardrobe, should you spend $4 on it or $40?

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Charcoal and Light Gray Fort Belvedere socks matched with Raphael's suit for a unified appearance
Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Charcoal and Light Gray Fort Belvedere socks matched with Raphael’s suit for a unified appearance

A Closer Look At $4 Socks

Size

I bought a 5-pack of Dockers Men’s Dress Socks for $20. So, that comes out to be $4 per pair. That seems like a good deal especially since they are sized and I got the size 10 to 13 because I’m typically a US 11. Of course, if you are on the edges of the size category, chances are they may be a little loose or quite tight. When I shopped for $4 socks, I came across much larger size brackets such as 6 to 12 or one size fits most.

Even though I fall within the size range, the problem is that there is so much elastics in there that actually pinches my calves over the course of the day. Not only that it restricts my blood flow, but it’s also quite uncomfortable.

One size fits all socks
One size fits all socks

Color

In terms of color on the website, it looks like they came in black and khakis and variations thereof. When I got them in person, there are solid, ripped khaki pairs, there’s an argyle pattern, there is a small pattern in brown and khaki but also two in brown. Although these tones work with khakis or maybe brown pants, you have a problem with any kind of business suit socks such as charcoal or navy or gray.

Also, we take a closer look at the solid socks; it’s really hard to match a pair of solid socks to a pair of patterned or solid pants because most of the time the shade is not quite matching and it just looks off. When we get our $4 socks, they’re pretty limited in the color range and you may find black or gray, something brownish or khaki but that’s about it.

A variation of solid black, a big pattern black, and khaki with argyle, tone-in-tone stripes and a diagonal dot pattern
A variation of solid brown, a big pattern brown, and khaki with argyle, tone-in-tone stripes, and a diagonal dot pattern socks

Length

Even though they’re advertised as dress socks, they’re actually mid-calf height and because of that, they don’t stay up. Gravity is just too strong over the course of the day, so they’ll just move down towards your ankle. As a consequence, it will probably expose your legs which is unprofessional because no one wants to see your hairy legs at the office. And no, even though you shave your legs, people still don’t want to see it.

Sock Garters can be uncomfortable for some
A short sock supported by suspender

Material

On the material mix on the website, it was advertised as 71% polyester, 26% cotton, 2% spandex, and 1% nylon, the actual package itself looks different. On the actual pack, it says 83% polyester, 15% cotton, and 2% spandex. Upon touching them, they feel quite soft and comfortable because polyester can be finished to be very soft these days.

Frankly though, polyester is the cheapest of all materials that you can use in your clothing but it also ages very poorly and quickly. How? Well, soon you’ll find pilling and it just won’t stand the test of time and always look like a hand me down that’s old and worn. Polyester is also insulating, which means that you’re more prone to sweating with these kinds of socks and just having worn feet over the course of the day.

but a sock doesn’t contain them all, actually common socks are usually made up of 3 yarns
A sock doesn’t contain them all, common socks are usually made up of 3 yarns

Verdict On $4 Socks

When I put on those socks, I noticed 2 things right away. One was how thick they were compared to a more expensive pair of socks; and two, the toe area: when you need a pair of socks, it has to be finished in this toe area because machines are not quite able to do that. If it’s done by machine, it’s usually very bulky and that’s exactly what you get with a $4 pair of socks. The problem is you will always feel this elevated seam inside your shoe especially when you walk a lot.

$40 vs $4 sock (Pictured: Burgundy Two Tone Solid Oxford Socks from Fort Belvedere)
$40 vs $4 sock (Pictured: Burgundy Two Tone Solid Oxford Socks from Fort Belvedere)

So, in nutshell, who are $4 socks for? They are for men who think short term, who want the cheapest pair of socks that they can find without having to resort to white tennis socks. They’re also for men who don’t mind sweaty feet and don’t really want a comfortable pair of socks.

A Closer Look At The $40 Socks

Size

What exactly makes them 10x as expensive? First of all, they are sized to your foot. Most high-end socks come in a number of different sizes and at Fort Belvedere, we offer 5 different sizes — Small, Medium, Large, Extra-large, and Extra Extra Large. This allows us to adequately cover the size ranges all the way from size 6 to size 15.

Fort Belvedere Sizing Chart
Fort Belvedere Sizing Chart

Length

Of course, if you look at the length difference, it is apparent. The more expensive $40 socks are the true over-the-calf sock that is below the knee and stays up all day comfortably. Over-the-calf socks are the gentlemen’s choice and at Fort Belvedere, we only offer that style, nothing mid-calf or shorter because they will just inevitably slide down and for me, it is really important to design a sock that stays up.

Colors

In our mind, the biggest advantage of a $40 socks compared to a $4 socks is their versatility. And I know most men don’t even think about that when they buy a pair of socks. Obviously, we love men’s style and we want you to look as good as possible.

Forty-dollar socks don’t just come in a much larger range of colors for you to choose from, but they typically also come in two different colors that are combined and the combination of that allows you to wear a single pair of socks with a multitude of outfits and pants and they will always look like it matches and works together versus a solid, plain color sock will always look off.

Different colors of Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks from Fort Belvedere
Different colors of Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks from Fort Belvedere
Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Burgundy and light grey Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Burgundy and light grey Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Light Grey and Light Blue Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Light Grey and Light Blue Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Light Brown and Blue Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Light Brown and Blue Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Grey and Turquoise Green Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Grey and Turquoise Green Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Charcoal and Orange Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Charcoal and Orange Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Dark Navy Blue and Royal Blue Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Dark Navy Blue and Royal Blue Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Dark Green and Purple Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Dark Green and Purple Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Navy Blue and Red Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Navy Blue and Red Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Just think about navy, charcoal, or gray for a second which are the most popular business colors. They properly come in hundreds, maybe even in thousands of different shades. If you have two colors combined, for example, a navy blue and a lighter blue, you can wear it with any shade of navy that’s always gonna work. Another example is a kind of a grayish blue and a light blue combined, which can work with any type of gray pants, charcoal pants or navy pants that will always look good. That’s the true hidden power of two-tone socks that most men underestimate.

Two-tone socks also work with different colors, for example, these socks are actually a combination of purple and white, and there is something that I would call a faux solid because from afar, they look like a solid but if you look closer, they are actually made up of two colors. They can be worn with any kind of brown pants and they look great. They can be worn with denim or maybe with something in charcoal or with a pair of chinos. That’s true versatility. 

Compared to this pair of socks in brown, it just doesn’t work with gray. Yes, it somewhat works with a brown, yes it works with chinos, it doesn’t look that great with any blue or denim.

What Makes Fort Belvedere Socks Special?

At Fort Belvedere, we try to design our socks so you’ll get a large range of different colors in two-tone patterns that work with a multitude of outfits. You also won’t find rocket ships or pizzas on our socks, as we generally find “crazy” socks to be overrated.

Fort Belvedere socks with clocks pattern
Fort Belvedere socks with clocks pattern
Mid Brown Socks with Green and Cream Clocks in Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Mid Brown Socks with Green and Cream Clocks in Cotton

Blue Socks with Red and White Clocks in Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Blue Socks with Red and White Clocks in Cotton

Grey Socks with Light Grey and Black Clocks in Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Grey Socks with Light Grey and Black Clocks in Cotton

Navy Socks with Blue and White Clocks in Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Navy Socks with Blue and White Clocks in Cotton

Dark Grey Socks with Burgundy and White Clocks in Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Dark Grey Socks with Burgundy and White Clocks in Cotton

Now, as you’ll imagine, a pair of $40 socks is made up of premium materials. For example, you can find silk, cashmere, or blends thereof. Even if socks are made up of cotton, not all cotton is alike. You can find cheaper cotton with shorter staple lengths or you can find higher-end cotton with a longer staple length that is twisted twice for consistency and longevity of the yarn and that way, you just end up with a sock that is much more comfortable because it is all made of natural fibers, not artificial fibers like nylon or polyester and that won’t insulate.

Fort Belvedere socks are hand finished in Italy
Fort Belvedere socks are hand finished in Italy

The reality is that just the raw material of a $40 socks costs more than the entire $4 socks. Because of that, you can make a yarn much thinner and knit a sock more finely. Of course, with a larger number of needles, it takes longer to make a pair of socks. However, the fine gauge knit of a high-end dress sock is always a hallmark because you will not be able to find any expensive sock that is fine as a high-quality sock.

Also, the machines used and the country of origin are typically different. All the $4 socks are made in China, Fort Belvedere socks are exclusively made in Italy of 100% natural fibers. And because there’s a tradition of craftsmanship and socks making in Italy, all the socks are finely finished by hand so there is no bulky seam at the toe that would provide any discomfort to you when you walk. Considering that cotton is absorbent and not as insulating as polyester, you will have just a much more pleasant experience walking around in your dress shoes throughout the day.

Is It Worth It to Pay 10x As Much?

Fort Belvedere offers volume discounts
Fort Belvedere offers volume discounts

Ultimately that is up for you to decide. In my book, it is definitely worth it, especially when you consider that you can buy a pair of 3, 6, or 12 socks and can bring the price down all the way to $30 per pair. That would allow you to get 12 different colors of socks, meaning, you’re basically equipped to handle any kind of situation with the right pair of socks.

It also makes travel easier because you can bring along a small amount of pair of socks and you don’t have to think about what color works exactly with it because you can be confident it’s gonna work out. 

Conclusion

Forty-dollar socks come in many sizes, the $4 socks come in very few or just 1 size. While the material of the cheaper socks won’t stand the test of time, the pilling will look bad and make you sweat, higher-end materials allow for thinner socks that look more elegant with your dress shoes and your fine outfit. They’re more breathable and overall more comfortable when you wear them.

Dinner jacket with black silk socks by Fort Belvedere and opera pumps aka court shoes
Sven Raphael Schneider wears a dinner jacket with black silk socks by Fort Belvedere and opera pumps

On top of that, $40 socks are true over-the-calf versus cheaper socks are mid-calf that cut off your circulation and just slide down top make you look unprofessional. Also, $4 socks are finished by machines in its toe area, making it less comfortable to wear them versus the $40 socks are finished by hand so you have a smooth result and don’t feel anything. Most importantly, while $4 socks usually come in colors of black, gray, brown, or khaki, $40 socks come in a range of 15 or 20 different colors especially in color combinations that allow you to really look your best without having to think about it very much.

Outfit Rundown

Raphael's casual outfit
Raphael’s casual outfit
Mid Brown and Green Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Fil d'Ecosse Cotton - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Mid Brown and Green Shadow Stripe Ribbed Socks Fil d'Ecosse Cotton

Two-Tone Knit Tie in Brown and Beige Changeant Silk - Fort Belvedere

Fort Belvedere

Two-Tone Knit Tie in Brown and Beige Changeant Silk

In today’s, video, I’m wearing a casual outfit that is built around the color green. It starts with a green cable-knit sweater and I combined it with a green checkered shirt as well as a brown knit tie.

My pants are of brownish green and a nice twill weave and my shoes are dark green suede test loafers with accents of brown. I combined them with a pair of green socks by Fort Belvedere that tied the entire outfit together seamlessly. Of course, my pinky ring has a green bloodstone which works with the entire outfit.

Reader Comments

  1. The gentleman who has been suggesting a signature tune was along the right lines but his idea should be refined to a siren to warn us whenever we are to read an advertisement for Fort Belvedere instead of an article

  2. I generally appreciate these comparisons, but this one is an infomercial. There are plenty of other manufacturers (not brands) with similar products too.

    1. What brands are you referring to specifically, and what would you like to see compared?

  3. I know that rules are made to be broken, but should socks (if they are solid or predominantly one color) be the same color as your pants or the same color as your shoes?

  4. Raphael – $ 4.00 socks – never. $ 12.00 – $ 18.00 socks sensible – cotton, wool, some blends. (multi-packs) Are you prepared to offer “customer satisfaction guaranteed” Fort Belvedere socks given reasonable washing and drying care???
    No equivocation now .

    Best/Jim

    P.S. given proper care – how many wearing’s for Fort Belvedere socks?

    1. Dear James,

      1. We are all different in what we value and appreciate. In my experience, there is not sensible blend of poly and cotton for example. I would always rather wear 100% cotton socks as they make my feet feel more comfortable and I sweat less.
      2. More expensive socks do not automatically last longer. For example a fine pair of silk or cashmere socks will likely last not as long as a pair of cotton socks. Also a pair of fine cotton socks with thin yarn will likely wear out faster than thick yarn cotton socks, even though the thicker yarn may be made of lower raw cotton material. If you want o compare apples to apples, you have to compare the same knit and yarn thickness.
      For me personally, a thick pair of socks is simply unattractive. Other do not like thin socks, it is simply a matter of preference.
      3. Every person has different feet, calluses, bones and shoes . A rough area may be all it takes to result in a hole.
      4. Unlike a $12-18 pair of socks, we are a brand that stands behind our quality and wants our customers to be happy, and we have replaced socks when customers were not happy with them.
      That being said, our main concern when it comes to socks is not just longevity. We want socks that stay up, are comfortable to wear and come in great color combinations that makes it easy and stylish for you to combine them. Given these factors we want the best, and longest yarn quality we can get, but there are definitely socks out there that last longer than ours.
      5. When you buy from us, you can rest assure that we repair or replace a product if something goes wrong or wears out too quickly. Other companies do not have such an approach.
      I have never found a pair of $12-18 socks that stayed up on my calves, so the longevity factor for me was a moot point as I would not wear the socks.
      6. If your main goal is to prove us wrong, and longevity is the only thing you care about in socks, maybe we are not a right brand fit for you.
      7. Maybe we will launch a sock that is made to last as long as possible, but it will have to be a thicker sock, and it will have some non-natural materials. You see, it is all a compromise.

      1. Raphael,
        Thank you so much for your confident, detailed reply. I intend to buy Fort Belvedere socks in the near future.
        Respectfully yours

        James I. Laursen

  5. This dissertation on socks is rather silly. I have been wearing socks with garters for at least the last 60 years. The only real difference might be the black lisle socks I wear with a dinner coat and pumps or knee socks worn in Bermuda.

    Also, in one of her earlier books in the fifties and sixties, Emily Post tells of the best dressed man she had ever met. He owned three suits, a blue blazer, a Harris tweed jacket, three pairs of slacks and evening clothes. One really needs very little if one’s clothes are of good quality.

    1. Spot on Charles!
      May I assume that “Proper Fit” is part of “good quality?”

      J.L.

  6. I disagree with the criticisms of many of the above comments that this article is just an advertisement for Ft Belvedere socks. I’ve found that when it comes to gentlemen’s menswear, you really do get what you pay for. Nowhere in the article does it say “You must buy our socks and only our socks.” Obviously there are other high quality mens dress socks out there. Raphael is simply explaining why at even 10x the price of a pair of cheap socks GG’s Ft Belvedere socks are a superior value. He’s not obligated to discuss his competitors.

    1. I totally agree with Bethune’s comment above… The fact is that a $40 pair of socks is definitely worth my money, my time and how I look.. and they’re definitely cheaper in the long term even vs $20 socks, at least in my experience.. Not to mention it in terms of comfort and style… I have always stuck to a point… if you want to save money, do not buy cheap things…

      Raphael’s articles discuss gentlemen’s style and he has been doing it for a long time, even before he started selling socks… and a nice array of beautiful things. Of course he mentions his socks… He is rightly proud of them…

  7. I must admit that the 40$ socks generally doesn’t do it for me – they seem quite coarse to my toes, and the elastics – well quite frankly just doesn’t cut it. I personally use 250$ socks, sure they are more expensive, but they feel a lot nicer in use, and you cannot put a price on comfort for your feet. I use about 10-12 pairs in a year, so it’s not THAT expensive when you think about it.

  8. Hey Raf,

    Where are the socks you mention, the two tone that appear one tone at a distance, you dont have them listed from sale

    1. Hi Scott! Those are prototypes but we’ll have those available soon, perhaps 6-8 weeks from now. :)

Comments are closed.